Home› New York› Amherst
2025 Annual Fire Report

Fires in Amherst, New York

In 2025, fire departments serving Amherst responded to 71 fire and hazmat incidents — from cooking fires to gas leaks to a single $75K building blaze. Here's the full picture.

Updated Sep 27, 2026 Grade A+ Peak yr 2023 Erie County 129,577 residents 3 reporting departments 510 5-yr
Total incidents
71
-22.8% vs 2024
Building fires
1
Residential 0% Other 100%
Property loss
$91K
$75K structure · $16K contents
Deaths & injuries
0 / 0
0 civilian deaths · 0 civ injuries · 0 firefighter injuries
01 The mix

What kinds of fires happen here?

Carbon monoxide incident lead by count. Building fires lead by dollars. Together the top five categories make up about 65% of all calls.

71
Total Incidents
Carbon monoxide incident 14 19.7%
Gas leak (natural gas or LPG) 11 15.5%
Cooking fire, confined to container 10 14.1%
Overheated motor 6 8.5%
Arcing, shorted electrical equipment 5 7.0%
All other categories 25 35.2%
02 Seasonality

When do fires happen?

Nov peaks. Mar dips. Watch for the typical fall climb starting in October.

Jan 4
Feb 5
Mar 3
Apr 6
May 5
Jun 5
Jul 5
Aug 3
Sep 9
Oct 7
Nov 15
Dec 4
Fewer
More
2b Five-year trend

Year over year in Amherst

510 incidents 2021–2025. Peak year was 2023. $83K cumulative property loss.

YearIncidentsYoY 
2021* 55 —
2022 133 —
2023 159 +19.5%
2024 92 -42.1%
2025 71 -22.8%

* Well below Amherst's usual volume. That almost always means one or more departments didn't submit a full year to NFIRS, not that fires dropped, so no year-over-year change is shown for it.

03 Cause of ignition

What sparks building fires?

For the 1 building fires Amherst departments responded to in 2025, here's how they were classified once investigators were finished.

Unintentional
100%
1
Cause undetermined
0%
0
Intentional / arson
0%
0
Equipment / heat source failure
0%
0
Under investigation
0%
0
Act of nature (lightning)
0%
0
3b Where fires start

Where do fires start in Amherst?

NFIRS Area of Origin (AREA_ORIG) for the 3 building fires investigators classified across 2021–2025. The room or location where ignition occurred — kitchens, bedrooms, exterior, vehicle areas — tells you where to focus prevention.

#Area of originCountShare 
1 Bathroom, checkroom, lavatory, locker room 1 33.3%
2 Laundry area, wash house (laundry) 1 33.3%
3 Undetermined 1 33.3%
3c What ignited it

What actually ignited the fire?

NFIRS Heat Source (HEAT_SOURC) — the physical thing that started it. Spark or ember from operating equipment, an open flame, smoking materials, or hot embers from a fireplace are the leading culprits nationwide. Here's the Amherst mix.

#Heat sourceCountShare 
1 Heat from powered equipment, other 1 33.3%
2 Hot or smoldering object, other 1 33.3%
3 Undetermined 1 33.3%
04 The biggest fires

2 fires · $75K in losses

Largest single-incident property losses reported by Amherst departments in 2025. These 2 fires alone account for 100% of the city's annual total.

# Property loss Type Severity Status
1 $75,000 Dumpster or other outside trash receptacle fire Significant Investigated
2 $100 Cooking fire, confined to container Significant Investigated
05 How Amherst compares

Amherst vs New York vs the nation

Per-capita rates let us compare apples to apples. Amherst sits below the national average for incidents per resident.

0.55
Incidents per 1,000 residents
Amherst
0.55
NY avg
3.48
US avg
7.48
0.01
Building fires per 1,000 residents
Amherst
0.01
NY avg
0.2
US avg
0.85
0
Civilian fire deaths per million
Amherst
0
NY avg
1
US avg
5.9
5c Wildfires nearby

Wildfires within 50 mi of Amherst

Top 7 wildfires (1992+) in the FPA-FOD ignitions database, scaled by acres. 111 acres burned in this 50-mile radius. Each dot is a fire — bigger dots burned more land.

50 mi radius
YearCauseAcresDistance 
1995 Smoking 25 42.7 mi
1995 Smoking 20 48.4 mi
2012 Debris and open burning 19 42.5 mi
2016 Debris and open burning 16 14.4 mi
2012 Missing data/not specified/undetermined 11 15.4 mi
2013 Natural 10 13.5 mi
2015 Arson/incendiarism 10 14.2 mi
5d Top ZIPs

Where in Amherst do fires concentrate?

Top 5 ZIP codes by NFIRS incident count across 2021–2025. Each ZIP has its own fire profile — dive in for neighborhood-level context.

#ZIP5-yr incidents 
1 14226 267
2 14228 226
3 14260 14
4 14221 2
5 14068 1
5e Peer cities

Cities similar to Amherst

Six New York cities with population within ±25% of Amherst. Useful comparison targets — same state, similar size, different fire profile.

06 First responders

Who responds in Amherst?

3 departments report to NFIRS for incidents in Amherst.

ELLICOTT CREEK FIRE DEPARTMENT
45 S ELLICOTT CREEK RD
FDID 15029
NORTH AMHERST FIRE DEPARTMENT
2200 TONAWANDA CREEK RD
FDID 15063
NORTH BAILEY FIRE DEPARTMENT
966 SWEET HOME RD
FDID 15064
07 Stay prepared

Before the next Red Flag day.

A 30-minute weekend can cut your home's exposure substantially. These four checklists are a good starting point.

About this data

Numbers reflect incidents reported by participating fire departments to the National Fire Incident Reporting System (NFIRS) Public Data Release for calendar year 2025. NFIRS is voluntary — about 23,000 of roughly 30,000 US fire departments report — so totals are a strong indicator, not a complete census. Per-capita comparisons use 2023 ACS population estimates. Wildland fire data complements NFIRS with NIFC and USFS perimeters. Active-fire counts come from a dated NIFC snapshot, not a live feed.